Skip to main content

Review of Green Day's American Idiot at Milton Keynes Theatre, Milton Keynes

As the audience take their seats for Green Day's American Idiot, a television screen drip feeds snippets of media coverage of both the 9/11 terrorist attacks and President Bush's subsequent war on terror. It's a significant part of the storyline that follows, although the story of disillusioned youths attempting to find themselves is nothing new.

These three particular disillusioned friends are Johnny (Tom Milner), Will (Samuel Pope) and Tunny (Joshua Dowen). Johnny and Tunny drop their homes in pursuit of "finding themselves" in the city, while Will has more homely issues dealing with his now pregnant girlfriend Heather (Siobhan O'Driscoll).


It's a strong enough story to create a show around, and with Green Day's remarkable lyrics on American Idiot (and a few extra choice songs in the second act), it proves affecting sometimes in a surprising way. The first act is unquestionably the strongest, the best first act I have had the pleasure to see at Milton Keynes actually, the best songs are here, and the best pieces of choreography are also. This is often where the strength is on this show, in the musical set pieces.

Racky Plews, who both directs and leads choreography has created some vibrant pieces full of energy and it's amazing at times that the cast can maintain it for the entire show. The choreography is neat in that it feels perfectly in keeping with how these people would dance, full on rugged, and almost possessed at times, and weaving sexual acts into them at times, it both amusing and at turns probably leaving you grateful you are not sitting next to your gran.

The three leads Milner, Pope and Dowen are all equally strong, capturing their characters' emotions extremely well. It is all broad and exaggerated in its style as is keeping with the power of the music itself, so, there is little room for calm, and indeed when calm does come in the second act, as Milner's Johnny totally stops the pace of the show with his hard-hitting drug scene, it comes as so much more of a shock.

Dowen deals with Tunny's story with as much emotion as he can muster from what is virtually devoid of dialogue, he and the other leads force their actions through the lyrics of the songs as much as they can, and much of the time it is very effective. So, while more dialogue might have been beneficial at times, it also, as a result, would have broken the drive of the show, so, perhaps here the writers have got it about right.

Luke Friend as St Jimmy, is one of the pre-requisite nowadays it seems, an ex-X-Factor contestant, and he is both strong and weak, he has huge strength in the powerful numbers, but the softer moments of the songs he performs are lost within the music at times. Another X-Factor contestant though is much stronger, Sam Lavery as Whatsername is tremendous, remarkably powerful voice, one of the strongest in the show, and so incredibly effective in putting raw emotion into her performance.

The collections of songs are at their best in act one, the weaving Jesus of Suburbia is a stunning piece of evolving music over nine minutes, and the style changes put into the musical arrangement are amazing, including the haunting moment from O'Driscoll. Milner's delivery of Boulevard of Broken Dreams is also another highlight, as is Wake Me Up in September, the best moment of act two.

Sara Perks has designed a typically dowdy and dingy stage, which never moves through the show, with scene changes from props and windows of opportunity, a neat Rupenzel like appearance of Whatshername is extremely clever staging. The band occupy the upper tier and bring tremendous music to the entire show, and while you might expect it to be too loud, it never is. It's nicely balanced.

American Idiot was a surprise, I don't think it is for everyone, despite the surprising fact of how varied the audience was. It's perhaps one to chose your companion carefully with, but in equal turns, it's also maybe for all generations. It's rude, crude, abrasive throughout, but it's also tremendously good. It's more than just a rock concert bolted onto a thin storyline that you might be led to be believed by some, and from me, there is no question it comes highly recommended, if only for that quite stunning first act.

A stunning sensory overload of both brilliant music and choreography create an amazingly strong show.
⭐⭐⭐⭐½

Performance reviewed: Tuesday 23rd April 2019 at Milton Keynes Theatre, Milton Keynes.
American Idiot runs at Milton Keynes Theatre until Saturday 27th April 2019 before continuing its tour.
Further details about Milton Keynes Theatre can be found at http://www.atgtickets.com/venues/milton-keynes-theatre/

Photos: Mark Dawson Photography
Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Review of The House She Built at The Black Diamond, Northampton

Independent theatre company Nerve Theatre was founded in January 2025, when its first original production, Broken Party , took to the stage at Benn Hall in Rugby. That was followed the same year by a modern retelling of Frankenstein . Now, for 2026, Nerve Theatre founder Mia Ballard has written and directed The House She Built , staged for three nights at The Black Diamond, Northampton. The House She Built , set in 1950s Hollywood, is a dark thriller influenced by the lives of Marilyn Monroe, Judy Garland, Elizabeth Taylor and Audrey Hepburn and their treatment as women within the cogs of Hollywood. Our leading lady here is Nancy Carlton, who returns to Mellor Brothers Productions to make one final film. But something awaits her, and the scene is set for a period thriller that explores the grimy world behind Hollywood's apparently glamorous days. Michaela Clement-Hayes leads the cast as Nancy Carlton, the star troubled by her past, but returning to her old studio for that final mov...
Read more

Review of Paranormal Activity at Milton Keynes Theatre

The low-budget film Paranormal Activity , first released in 2007, has since become the starting point of one of the most prolific horror series ever, with seven films now released in the franchise and another due next year. Its unique down-to-earth style of storytelling, inhabiting what is many people’s real life, with dangers within the house, has contributed greatly to its success. So, from one successful medium franchise, it is no surprise the series was developed for theatre in 2024, with a new story by Levi Holloway (though it borrows heavily from the original film). First performed at Leeds Playhouse before heading to both the West End and Broadway, and now, for 2026, a UK and Ireland tour, which this week arrives at Milton Keynes Theatre. So the question is: has the medium successfully crossed to the other side? Newly married couple, James and Lou, move from Chicago to London in an attempt to escape both of their past lives. However, as events begin to repeat themselves, they re...
Read more

Review of Legally Blonde at Royal & Derngate (Derngate), Northampton

As I settled down in my chair at the Derngate to see this touring production of the musical Legally Blonde , I generally had no idea what I was letting myself in for. Never having seen the film, read little up on the show, as is my want, and sitting in a clearly unbalanced gender demographic, this show was quite clearly not targeted at me. As the opening number, a catchy, but the incredibly screechy song, Omigod You Guys was performed, I was not, let's say, won over at first. However, it was clear that this just served as an overwhelming and ridiculous setup to the boldness of the show. The second number, Serious was a much better experience and genuinely funny song and throughout the tracks to come, there was much better to come. Our lead is Elle Woods (a charming, bubbly Lucie Jones), a typical caricatured blonde whose sole aim in life is to get the hand of her love in life Warner Huntingdon III (Liam Doyle). When he breaks up with her in pursuit of someone "serious...
Read more