Skip to main content

Review of An Improbable Musical at Royal & Derngate (Royal), Northampton

If there is one thing we all need at the moment, it is a good dose of fun, and with Improbable’s An Improbable Musical, fun, comedy, and randomness are at its very heart. Over the course of roughly ninety minutes, this was a convoluted path through a story bred from just three ideas from the audience, and indeed a hefty amount of rehearsing. Yes, this is improv at its heart, but much like the great Morecambe and Wise looked off the cuff, there is a huge amount of rehearsing, rehearsing, rehearsing involved to get a fluidity such as this.

Our artists for the night were Janet Etuk, Niall Ashdown, Ruth Bratt and Adam Courting and perhaps the most familiar, Josie Lawrence. For the press evening of the run, sadly, the sixth performer Aya Nakamura was having to isolate. Musicians Max Gittings, Joley Cragg, Juliet Colyer and Christopher Ash as the musical director joined onstage with these performers.

An Improbable Musical took stimulus for its performance from the audience by asking just three simple questions. The first, a favourite place, which was selected to be “the lakes” and elaborated with the fact that it was “because it is full of water”, a sentiment that would provide much material on the evening, not least from Josie Lawrence. The second question was a word that delighted your mouth when you said it, and they chose this as “chocolate”. Finally, the audience were given the opportunity to give an opening line, and a star member of the audience provided “the house is on fire, and this time it isn’t my fault”.

From these embers of ideas, the musical developed, and not always how you would expect. For instance, Lawrence twisted the house burning line from its initial impact of humour to a poignant line in a song describing the breakdown of a marriage. Elsewhere, chocolate provided a rather brilliant scene involving the making of the sweet substance, brimming with humour, and then the undying love from every member of the group for Lawrence’s character. This comic scene involving mugs and teapots then cleverly segued into a beautiful and clever puppetry scene involving three ducks upon the lakes.

That was the perfect collection of use of the three ideas from the audience, and indeed it continued throughout the evening as the central story of a wife moving out and leaving her train loving husband opened and ended the evening, alongside several other brilliant scenes featuring often simple, but hilarious characters.

You could constantly see as each scene opened, they had come straight out of the rehearsal room, carefully prepared in a way that improv only can be. Key among the scenes was a contemporary dance scene which you felt sure was a box that needed to ticked for each performance, and as it continued, the audience might have been unsure what was going to happen and how it would work (and maybe the cast as well at first), but then, bang, Adam Courting brought it into reason. These were the commune members, already mentioned as neighbouring our couple’s house, and then, of course, their chant crashed back to be linked to the lakes.

It is amazing to see how it works, how the performers become so intuitive to each other, and indeed save one another when things don’t seem to go anywhere, as Ashdon did saving what appeared to be a startled hare Courting in the centre of the stage at one point. This is teamwork of the highest order, someone always has your back.

Part of that team also are the excellent musicians as well. Gittins, Cragg, Colyer and Ash just seemed to know when and where they are required, with the music beginning at what seemed just the perfect point every time. They also occasionally become even more part of the action as Gittings did very much at one particularly amusing point.

The set from E M Parry is a thing of simplicity in its requirements, just a staircase and a door and a revolve of the two levels, which provides the performers a playground beyond their usual domain of just the stage before it. Elsewhere on stage seems to be a collection of every prop you could imagine, ready for action, be it a suitcase or a top hat and feather boa.

The songs that were performed were a brilliant collection, and often disturbingly more memorable and catchy than some I have heard in “proper” musicals. I know for sure that Single, and Ready to Mingle, is likely to flash back now and again as an earworm, if nothing more than for the memory of how brilliantly and comically Ashdown performed it. Other memorable moments that will never be seen or heard again included cacao and the swan, both involving the brilliant Bratt.

So, there is my review of a show that you will never see, even if you purchase a ticket and head to the Royal & Derngate before Saturday to see An Improbable Musical, and that you should (and as my additional ticket now suggests, so am I). This is a rollicking evening of entertainment of which neither you, nor the performers, will know where the show is heading, until it finally gathers pace and rolls to its almost certain hilarious destination.

Clever, funny, random, a perfect evening of improv madness awaits you.
⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐

Performance reviewed: Tuesday 1st March 2022 at the Royal & Derngate (Royal), Northampton.
An Improbable Musical runs at Royal & Derngate until Saturday 5th March 2022.

For further details about the Royal & Derngate see their website at http://www.royalandderngate.co.uk

An Improbable Musical is A ROYAL & DERNGATE, NORTHAMPTON AND IMPROBABLE PRODUCTION

Production photos: Marc Brenner


Popular posts from this blog

Review of The House She Built at The Black Diamond, Northampton

Independent theatre company Nerve Theatre was founded in January 2025, when its first original production, Broken Party , took to the stage at Benn Hall in Rugby. That was followed the same year by a modern retelling of Frankenstein . Now, for 2026, Nerve Theatre founder Mia Ballard has written and directed The House She Built , staged for three nights at The Black Diamond, Northampton. The House She Built , set in 1950s Hollywood, is a dark thriller influenced by the lives of Marilyn Monroe, Judy Garland, Elizabeth Taylor and Audrey Hepburn and their treatment as women within the cogs of Hollywood. Our leading lady here is Nancy Carlton, who returns to Mellor Brothers Productions to make one final film. But something awaits her, and the scene is set for a period thriller that explores the grimy world behind Hollywood's apparently glamorous days. Michaela Clement-Hayes leads the cast as Nancy Carlton, the star troubled by her past, but returning to her old studio for that final mov...

Review of Paranormal Activity at Milton Keynes Theatre

The low-budget film Paranormal Activity , first released in 2007, has since become the starting point of one of the most prolific horror series ever, with seven films now released in the franchise and another due next year. Its unique down-to-earth style of storytelling, inhabiting what is many people’s real life, with dangers within the house, has contributed greatly to its success. So, from one successful medium franchise, it is no surprise the series was developed for theatre in 2024, with a new story by Levi Holloway (though it borrows heavily from the original film). First performed at Leeds Playhouse before heading to both the West End and Broadway, and now, for 2026, a UK and Ireland tour, which this week arrives at Milton Keynes Theatre. So the question is: has the medium successfully crossed to the other side? Newly married couple, James and Lou, move from Chicago to London in an attempt to escape both of their past lives. However, as events begin to repeat themselves, they re...

Review of Annie at Milton Keynes Theatre

Annie was first performed now a remarkable fifty years ago at Goodspeed Opera House in Connecticut, and since then, the tale based on a 1920s comic strip and adapted for the stage by Thomas Meehan on book, with music by Charles Strouse, and lyrics provided by Martin Charnin, has become a perennial favourite across the world. Indeed, this version, directed by Nikolai Foster, last appeared at Milton Keynes Theatre in 2023. So, after all these years, does Annie still have that appeal? Set in  1930s New York during the Great Depression,  Annie  follows the life of an orphan abandoned to the care  of its evil matron, Miss Hannigan. Annie seeks escape, and after one failed attempt, she finds herself the chosen Christmas guest of billionaire Oliver Warbucks, and things slowly, hopefully begin to improve for the little but fiercely strong Annie. Leading the adult cast for this tour now as the cruel Miss Hannigan is Claire Sweeney. Sweeney clearly revels in the chance to embr...