Review of Cluedo 2 at Milton Keynes Theatre

Back in 2022, the original Cluedo stage play, based on a 1985 play by Sandy Rustin, itself based on the cult US film Clue, journeyed to Milton Keynes Theatre as part of a UK tour. It was, it has to be said, an average affair, made good by some excellent staging and at times a very fair tribute to the original board game. Now two years later, the success of that tour clearly warranted a return to the franchise and we find Cluedo 2 now on stage at Milton Keynes Theatre. So, is a follow-up warranted, and does it address many of the issues of the original? Let's find out.

Unlike the original and with no film source material to create a second play from, legendary TV comedy writers Maurice Gran and Lawrence Mark have taken the helm to provide the script for this production. Sadly, the legendary writers have for the best part plowed through their archives of extremely dated, and tiresome comedy. Much of the script is heavy on the obvious, high on the cringe, and while at times it can bring a titter (and in some audience members, a constant guffaw), this really is very tired material.

What is worse from Gran and Mark's play is that it isn't really honouring Cluedo as a game. The original worked into the format, with multiple endings and some mystery to the story that those taking part in the board game had when playing. Here, the murder mystery and story is heavy-handed and just created as a comic farce with hardly any link to the Cluedo game bar the names of the characters, and the location.

The cast, many of them excellent in their stage performances and presence in the show, have often the most appalling material to perform. To see the likes of successful screen actor Jason Durr as Colonel Mustard having to "giddy-up" back and forth across the stage is awkward and cringe. Elsewhere, the other "name" in the show, Ellie Leach, fresh from Strictly Come Dancing victory, in her stage debut as Miss Scarlett, seems out of her depth and wondering what might be going on in a very flat, monotonous performance. Some of the other cast seem to be dealing with the material a little better, including a likable Jack Bennett as Wadsworth. However, like much of the show, his character never develops and becomes repetitive eventually, especially with his "I'm not a butler!" line being done to death.

Repetition raises its ugly head in scene changes as well, which are, initially excellent, and truly funny and clever. However, after a while, these also begin to repeat in multiple uses of walking by artwork and billiards room play. Funny the first time (and maybe the second), but eventually just overused with no progression.

The set from David Farley is simplicity itself, but not in a good way. Even for a touring production, this is extremely minimal and provides little backdrop for the multiple locations depicted. As a result, we have to be told where we are often by a huge version of the board from the game lighting up specific locations. The mention of lighting brings us to another disaster for the show, with just appalling lighting leaving many cast members in darkness while delivering key lines. Yes, this is a dark and dingy manor during a storm, but it would still be nice to see the cast.

Cluedo 2 isn't without its successes. There are a few really funny moments, including suitably enough from the many death scenes, which are very much the highlights of the show. However the good bits are few and far between, and the ending provides just an endless succession of pointless moments, finishing on a chaotic and confused low. Sadly a disappointing return to the manor.

Tired, dated comedy provides no improvement sadly on an average original.
⭐⭐

Performance reviewed: Tuesday 16th April 2024 at the Milton Keynes Theatre.

Cluedo 2 runs at Milton Keynes Theatre until Saturday 20th April 2024.

For further details about Milton Keynes see their website at http://www.atgtickets.com/venues/milton-keynes-theatre/

Production photos: Alastair Muir

Review of Broken Party at The Benn Hall, Rugby

Broken Party , now on stage at The Benn Hall, is the first production by the new theatre company Nerve Theatre. Written and directed by company founder Mia Ballard, it provides an impressive collection of twists and turns that will please thriller enthusiasts. The story setup sees a gathering of the Lewis family to celebrate the birthday of Abigail. She is the daughter of Ann Lewis and the leading player, James, a high-flying lawyer who sets his stall out in the world as a supporter of the victims of society. However, as events unravel due to a television interview, is he the worthy man many believe him to be? Ballard's script is a perfect smorgasbord of murder mystery aperitifs, a dinner party, and a collection of the most dislikeable individuals, each of whom is the ideal culprit for guilt. The story is told in a single-location living room with little distraction and sees the Lewis family spar against one another following a somewhat awkward viewing of a TV show. The dialogue fr...

Review of The Woman Who Cooked Her Husband at The Playhouse Theatre, Northampton

During the interval of The Woman Who Cooked Her Husband , last weeks production at The Playhouse Theatre Northampton, I got involved in a conversation between a couple sitting next to me. The lady was very much of the opinion that the play was a comedy, while the gentleman, had formed one that it was a tragedy. They were joking of course in the conversation, but it did highlight the differences that Debbie Isitt's dark comedy might have between the sexes. And also now perhaps the passing of time. When this was written in the nineties, Isitt's play was a forthright feminist play, heralding the championing over of the ladies over the man. One the ex-wife plotting to cook him, the other, the new lover, potentially already very tired of him after just three years. The husband, Kenneth (Jem Clack) elopes initially in pursuit of sex with Laura (Diane Wyman), after his nineteen years of marriage with Hilary (Corinna Leeder) has become tired and passionless. Then later, he elopes ...

Review of Kinky Boots (N.M.T.C.) at Royal & Derngate (Derngate), Northampton

The musical Kinky Boots is perhaps the perfect show for the homegrown theatre group Northampton Musical Theatre Company to perform with the very core of the story bred within this very county. The tale of of Charlie Price and his encounter and unlikely partnership with a certain Lola is based on a true story of factory W. G. Brooks Ltd and the owner Steve Pateman. Back in 1999 his story of men and their wearing of shoes for women featured on a BBC documentary and this in turn inspired the 2005 film, Kinky Boots . Finally, in 2012, this musical adaptation of the story hit the stage, with a book by Harvey Fierstein and songs written by Cyndi Lauper. Longtime readers of my blog with good memories may remember that five years ago I reviewed the opening of the UK professional tour of Kinky Boots , also at the Royal & Derngate. While I enjoyed the show, I didn't give it the most favourable review. Five years on, and a second viewing, have I warmed to the charms of Charlie and Lola...

A Small Mind At The Theatre

Search This Blog