Skip to main content

Review of Paranormal Activity at Milton Keynes Theatre

The low-budget film Paranormal Activity, first released in 2007, has since become the starting point of one of the most prolific horror series ever, with seven films now released in the franchise and another due next year. Its unique down-to-earth style of storytelling, inhabiting what is many people’s real life, with dangers within the house, has contributed greatly to its success. So, from one successful medium franchise, it is no surprise the series was developed for theatre in 2024, with a new story by Levi Holloway (though it borrows heavily from the original film). First performed at Leeds Playhouse before heading to both the West End and Broadway, and now, for 2026, a UK and Ireland tour, which this week arrives at Milton Keynes Theatre. So the question is: has the medium successfully crossed to the other side?
Newly married couple, James and Lou, move from Chicago to London in an attempt to escape both of their past lives. However, as events begin to repeat themselves, they realise the supernatural tends to follow you wherever you run.
Paranormal Activity feels immensely natural, with conversation between James (James Bye) and Lou (Hannah Sinclair Robinson) being some of the most normal chat in many a recent play. This helps, over the first twenty minutes or so, create comfort in the audience before this normal world begins to break down.
Only the conversation allows this, however, as director Felix Barrett has already created discomfort at the very beginning with a prolonged, total blackout, where all the terrors in anyone's mind are allowed to breed. From this, we shift to a slightly nervy but still very normal way of life for our two main players. Their attempts to move away from past troubles - James with a new job in London, and Lou continuing her remote role feel normal. So does the presence of James’s mother, who seems to have an overbearing presence in his life, which he is perhaps wise to try to escape. So, with domesticity sometimes feeling normal, the arrival of the fully expected supernatural feels creepier since it could happen in any of our homes.
James Bye plays James in a suitably contrasting way, evolving from a confident, somewhat cocky, and dismissive attitude towards Lou's behaviour to something very different once he can no longer deny what he's seeing. His chemistry with Hannah Sinclair Robinson as Lou is superb, and their relationship feels natural and believable throughout, even when events become difficult to bear. Robinson is equally strong, portraying the breakdown and challenges of both Lou’s past and present in a stark way. We feel her pain, especially early on when we know the things are real, but James refuses, or cannot, believe them.
Caroline Faber also provides excellent support as the domineering mother eager to come over and help her son and his new wife in their new life, and she serves as a constant reminder of James's hidden past. Jo Castleton also delivers a brief but animated performance as paranormal investigator Etheline Cotgrave, arriving at what becomes a pivotal moment in James and Lou’s lives.
Technically, Paranormal Activity is superb, using every stage trick in the book to unnerve and thrill the audience. Chris Fisher’s illusions keep the audience guessing what might happen next, and he brings some big, immensely clever moments to the stage. Anna Watson’s lighting design works side by side brilliantly with these illusions to create a creepy atmosphere, full of menacing shadows and further keeping the audience on edge as they were sure they saw something then, or did they?
Further unease comes from excellent sound design by Gareth Fry and Luke Halls's incredibly clever video design. Together with one of the most detailed touring sets from Fly Davis, these elements complete a masterpiece from the show's creatives.
Paranormal Activity is one of the best horror/thriller shows currently touring, creating an excellent atmosphere of dread rather than relying totally on jump scares. Sometimes less is more, and here the show does just the right amount to create an excellent show woven around a clever and ultimately fulfilling storyline. I fully enjoyed the ride, and I highly recommend this show if it comes near you on tour, or if you can catch it in London while it remains on stage at the Ambassadors Theatre.

A technical masterpiece filled with chills aplenty.
⭐⭐⭐⭐

Performance reviewed: Tuesday 15th September 2026 at the Milton Keynes Theatre.

Paranormal Activity runs at Milton Keynes Theatre until Saturday, 19th September 2026, before continuing its tour.

For further details about Milton Keynes Theatre, see their website at https://www.atgtickets.com/venues/milton-keynes-theatre/

For further details of the tour, see the website at https://paranormalonstage.com/uk-ireland-tour/


Photographs: Johan Persson
(Images represent the London production portraying alternative casting.)



Popular posts from this blog

Review of Cruel Intentions: The '90s Musical at Royal & Derngate (Derngate), Northampton

Cruel Intentions , released in the final year of the nineties, is a fondly regarded classic from the era, rammed with a collection of young and up-and-coming stars. Based on the classic Les Liaisons dangereuses , Roger Kumble's nineties update was clever and current; however, a quarter of a century later and now playing at Royal & Derngate, does it still work, and more importantly, does it work as a musical? The quick answer to the latter is no, but theatre persists, so what about the story? Kumble's adaptation tells of two wealthy step-siblings, Sebastian Valmont and Kathryn Merteul, sex-obsessed, constantly warring, and attracted to one another. When they begin a bet for Sebastian to deflower the new headmaster's daughter, Annette Hargrove, before the start of term, events spiral quickly out of control. Following in the footsteps of the well-remembered performers from the film does weigh on the cast. Will Callan, playing Sebastian, and Nic Myers, as Kathryn, are fine ...
Read more

Review of Annie at Milton Keynes Theatre

Annie was first performed now a remarkable fifty years ago at Goodspeed Opera House in Connecticut, and since then, the tale based on a 1920s comic strip and adapted for the stage by Thomas Meehan on book, with music by Charles Strouse, and lyrics provided by Martin Charnin, has become a perennial favourite across the world. Indeed, this version, directed by Nikolai Foster, last appeared at Milton Keynes Theatre in 2023. So, after all these years, does Annie still have that appeal? Set in  1930s New York during the Great Depression,  Annie  follows the life of an orphan abandoned to the care  of its evil matron, Miss Hannigan. Annie seeks escape, and after one failed attempt, she finds herself the chosen Christmas guest of billionaire Oliver Warbucks, and things slowly, hopefully begin to improve for the little but fiercely strong Annie. Leading the adult cast for this tour now as the cruel Miss Hannigan is Claire Sweeney. Sweeney clearly revels in the chance to embr...
Read more

Review of Lord of the Dance at Milton Keynes Theatre

On what was so far the hottest day of the year, and the highest in many a record book, it feels a tad evil to watch as a group of extremely talented performers bring to the stage one of the most famous and most energetic dance shows to tour. However, arriving now at Milton Keynes Theatre, as part of what is now the still rather immodestly titled 30 Years of Standing Ovations tour, Lord of the Dance remains full of energy even on the hottest of evenings in Milton Keynes. I last and first saw Lord of the Dance as part of the 25 Years of Standing Ovations tour, four years ago (yes, the sums don’t quite work), and it was every bit as spectacular as you could imagine this world-famous dance show is. Born into the world from Michael Flatley and the Riverdance spectacular that preceded it, Lord of the Dance is a simple but effective battle between good and evil and the resolution of it through dance rather than fighting. The dancing here is, as expected, exceptional, led by the Lord of the...
Read more