Skip to main content

Review of A Christmas Carol - A Ghost Story at Birmingham Rep

Charles Dickens's novella A Christmas Carol is a perennial favourite and over the years has been adapted countless times for television, film and here, with this adaptation by Mark Gatiss, subtitled A Ghost Story, a further stage version. Originally performed at the Nottingham Playhouse in 2022 before moving to London at the Alexandra Palace, and the same venues repeated the following year, its past success serves well for a further revival. Therefore for 2024, The Birmingham Rep has taken to staging their own production, with a mostly new cast including Matthew Cottle and Rufus Hound leading an excellent cast.

Cottle as Ebenezer Scrooge is excellent, often exhibiting a much more sprightly Scrooge that we would remember, and also, much funnier at times. Despite Gatiss remaining remarkably faithful to the original, the show, directed with excellent pace by Adam Penford mines more comedy than you might expect. Cottle's Scrooge remains without question evil, but in his delivery and mannerisms, the unexpected moments suddenly fill the audience with laughter.

In this production, Scrooge has a nice sparring opening scene with his old work colleague Jacob Marley before his demise, so, this allows Rufus Hound in the role a little extra before his destiny of chain burdens begin. This scene between the two is fabulous, totally sparky in delivery and gives the audience the potential to see that incredibly Scrooge is actually the better person of the two. Later as the ghostly Marley, Hound is oppressing, agonised and much the different character, creating a lovely moment showing his despair at how his life in death became due to his life during it.

There is an equally strong cast as well throughout the company. Grace Hogg-Robinson is a dancing and set climbing sprite of a Ghost of Christmas Past leading Scrooge through his life both before and after his love of money began, including his would be life with Belle, the love, briefly, of his youth, played delightfully by Kalifa Taylor. Of his past story, it is perhaps sad we do not learn why Scrooge changes so much. Here in one moment, he and Belle are to be married, and then in a instant, Belle is casting her ring back in Scrooge's face with no real inkling of why he has changed so much.

Mark Theodore is a commanding Ghost of Christmas Present, dragging Scrooge around the world he lives in and finding out the way people see him. Christmas Present also has a "magic dust" which enthuses those around him and this in part allows some of the excellent movement direction from Georgina Lamb to come to the fore, particularly during the Crachit's Christmas lunch. Theodore also, as do most of the cast, portray other characters through the story, and he is particular strong in the always crowd pleasing role of Fezziwig, and his leading of the dance is one of the highlights of the production.

Among the rest of the cast, Geoffrey Beevers is a delightful Narrator bridging scenes together with his calm presence to one corner of the stage and delivery of the true Dickensian language with style. Oscar Batterham is a pleasant, always generous and friendly Bob Cratchit, despite being both under the thumb of Scrooge and trying to feed both a full household while also coping with the sickly Tiny Tim, endearingly played by Ryan Weston. Indeed the cast is full of delightful, multiple performances to bring the story to life and no one disappoints.

Visually this version is a masterpiece, from the towering sets of filing cabinets of set designer Paul Wills alongside his equally great costume design, to the evocative sound from Ella Wahlström creating every tinkle of London and every scaring breath of ghostly form. Nina Dunn brings just the right amount of video design to the show without it overpowering the production. Also there are some superb puppets brought to life by designer Matthew Forbes, including some suitably creepy dolls that climb unrelenting up the Ghost of Christmas Present's jacket. Throughout all this, Adam Penford's brisk direction keeps both the actors and the story moving, allowing very little to slow proceedings.

A Christmas Carol - A Ghost Story is a delight, perhaps not as groundbreakingly different as you might expect a writer such as Gatiss to create, seemingly penned in by his need to be so utterly faithful to the original rather than to bring his own spin on the story. However, what it does do, is give an old and new generation a chance once again see a true classic story of morality one the stage, and comes highly recommended.

A faithful and visually impressive version of a classic work.
⭐⭐⭐⭐


Performance reviewed: Wednesday 20th November 2024 at The Birmingham Rep Theatre.

A Christmas Carol: A Ghost Story plays at the Birmingham Rep Theatre until Sunday 5th January 2025.

For further details about the Birmingham Rep and to book tickets see their website at https://www.birmingham-rep.co.uk/

Production Photos: Ellie Kurttz


Popular posts from this blog

Review of Annie at Milton Keynes Theatre

Annie was first performed now a remarkable fifty years ago at Goodspeed Opera House in Connecticut, and since then, the tale based on a 1920s comic strip and adapted for the stage by Thomas Meehan on book, with music by Charles Strouse, and lyrics provided by Martin Charnin, has become a perennial favourite across the world. Indeed, this version, directed by Nikolai Foster, last appeared at Milton Keynes Theatre in 2023. So, after all these years, does Annie still have that appeal? Set in  1930s New York during the Great Depression,  Annie  follows the life of an orphan abandoned to the care  of its evil matron, Miss Hannigan. Annie seeks escape, and after one failed attempt, she finds herself the chosen Christmas guest of billionaire Oliver Warbucks, and things slowly, hopefully begin to improve for the little but fiercely strong Annie. Leading the adult cast for this tour now as the cruel Miss Hannigan is Claire Sweeney. Sweeney clearly revels in the chance to embr...

Review of An Inspector Calls at Milton Keynes Theatre

First performed in 1945, J. B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls is a remarkable play, a morality play of the highest order, a study of character, an examination of the soul within us all. Unsurprisingly, this is always in production due to its strong characters, perfect for any actor to devour and digest. Therefore, with little surprise, it is back at Milton Keynes Theatre again, with many a GCSE student in the audience, as it remains on the curriculum. So, with so much potential, this couldn't go wrong as a production. Could it? An Inspector Calls tells the story of a Birling family dinner rudely interrupted by a forthright inspector, Goole. He arrives with news of the death, by suicide, of a 24-year-old girl and challenges each one present on how they may have come to influence the girl's decision. From an acting point of view, director Stephen Daldry's production is excellent, with a strong cast bringing the Birling family, plus one, to the stage. The leader of the h...

Review of The Brittas Empire at Stantonbury Theatre, Milton Keynes

Those old enough to remember may have recollections of the nineties sitcom The Brittas Empire , written by Richard Fegen and Andrew Norriss. Starring Chris Barrie, the wacky series follows the exploits of Gordon Brittas, the man with a dream and a leisure centre in Whitbury New Town to fulfil it, despite the numerous consequences that result. I loved it, and when I heard that MKTOC (Milton Keynes Theatre of Comedy) were to produce the world premiere of the stage show at Stantonbury Theatre, I had to be there to see it. Adapted by Steve Clark (who also directs) and Emma Dell (who also plays the neurotic Helen Brittas), they have put together a loving and fully understanding script based on stories and situations from many episodes, which are ideally suited for the stage. Taking on such a unique show is dangerous for both adapters and cast. Still, the group has perfectly pitched the characters so that they are instantly recognisable from those we remember on screen. Rob Simpson takes on ...