Skip to main content

Review of The Commitments at Milton Keynes Theatre

Roddy Doyle’s The Commitments, a tale of a group of unemployed young people in Dublin who start a soul band, first hit the bookshelves in 1987 and was followed in 1991 by the cult film of the same name. Surprisingly it wasn’t until 2013 that the stage musical first appeared, and debuted at the Palace Theatre in London. So, years after publication, and almost ten years after the stage premiere, is this still a relevant and entertaining prospect?

The quick answer is yes, as a delightful wave of nostalgia and comedy permeates the entire evening. The script is sharp, colourful and always interesting and the cast is superb across the board, including as ever a very strong ensemble.

James Killeen as Jimmy is tasked with the role of manager and getting the band together and he is full of character as much in the background keeping as tight a grip on this motley gang of youngsters (and one OAP) as possible, as when at the forefront. I also delighted in his rather sweet solo number, pining for an ability to sing as well.

Ian McIntosh, hot on the heels from his lead in the UK tour of We Will Rock You, is so much better here as the star of the band Deco. McIntosh’s talent in that previous show seemed subdued, but his musical ability here is superb, powering out a series of numbers, including a blistering performance of I Heard It Through The Grapevine and a constant twinkle in the eye as the character you love to hate. For those certain few as well, many will relish his strip to the briefest of briefs ahead of The Commitment’s first public performance close to the end of the second act.

The poster of The Commitments declares “starring Coronation Street legend Nigel Pivaro”, however, don’t come to the show for that, as starring is very loosely applied here, as while he does very little wrong, his role pretty much consists of sitting reading a newspaper and saying “shite” at a few occasions. A box-ticking and ticket-seller policy of the poorest magnitude really. Come for the rest of the cast instead.

Ciara Mackey as Imelda, Eve Kitchingman as Natalie and Sarah Gardiner as Bernie are a delight as The Commitmentettes. Constantly sparky personalities and they create some delightful harmonies in their performances.

Working through The Commitmentettes is randy OAP of the group Joey the Lips, and Stuart Reid plays the role well, but, it is extremely odd casting with the pool of talent out there not to cast someone appropriate to the age, rather than to obviously age up a younger performer. No criticism at all of Reid, but, definitely a disappointing decision made by casting.

The rest of the group is excellent as is the ensemble in general. There is a delightful turn by Ronnie Yorke as the thug with a heart Mickah, really entertaining. Also noticeable for his impact on the ensemble is Ed Thorpe, extremely humorous in many of his little turns in the background.

The musical numbers are, as expected, excellent, and this is where the meat of the show of course is, so, these don’t want to be a disappointment. While none of them was disappointing, without question the musical number of the show is Papa Was A Rolling Stone. It was a simply excellent moment and the highlight of the whole show.

The brevity of the story, the novel on which it is based in only 144 pages, for instance, does result in the story being over quite early in the second act. Therefore to counteract the fact that this means the show is relatively short, The Commitments has an extremely long curtain call of music. It is excellent in that it allows the performers to further showcase their talent, especially Gardiner, and also McIntosh, who also manages to showcase his talent of repartee with the audience during his numbers. However there might be some though who desire a more solid storyline and then just a couple of rousing reprises of numbers from the show for the curtain call, and those that do might find themselves itching for the end of this show’s final showcase.

The Commitments is not quite as good as anticipated perhaps. The story is very, very slight and leaves too many characters plying for our attention and as a result, we just end up knowing them for an over-emphasised characteristic and have no room to find the character at their soul. More story, more time to tell the story as well, and less of the would-be concert at the end, and this could have been a must-see. As it is, it still comes recommended but set your bar a little lower and you might be more pleasantly still entertained.

The Commitments entertains but lacks a little depth and soul to be a classic.

Performance reviewed: Monday 24th October 2022 at the Milton Keynes Theatre, Milton Keynes.

The Commitments runs at Milton Keynes Theatre until Saturday 29th October 2022.

For further details about Milton Keynes see their website at http://www.atgtickets.com/venues/milton-keynes-theatre/

Production photos: Ellie Kurttz


Popular posts from this blog

Review of Murder She Didn't Write at Royal & Derngate (Royal), Northampton

Murder She Didn't Write , stopping off for a four-day run at Royal & Derngate on a lengthy UK tour, treads the now well-worn path of an improvisational evening of theatre entertainment. Unsurprisingly, from the title, this show from Degrees of Error's takes a murder mystery as its inspiration, with the story influenced by ideas from the audience each evening. Due to this, Murder She Didn't Write and a review are very much an individual affair. What I saw in my evening at the theatre will differ significantly from what the audience will see the following evening; however, the fine performers will remain. The touring cast, in no particular order, is Lizzy Skrzypiec, Rachael Procter-Lane, Peter Baker, Caitlin Campbell, Stephen Clements, Douglas Walker, Harry Allmark, Rosalind Beeson, Sylvia Bishop, Emily Brady, Alice Lamb, Sara Garrard, Peta Maurice and Matthew Whittle. For my performance, Skrzypiec, Procter-Lane, Baker, Walker, Bishop, and Clements were on stage alongsid...

Review of Immune by R&D Youth Theatre at Royal & Derngate (Royal), Northampton

The cover note for the script of Oladipo Agboluaje's Immune describes it as "a challenging science fiction play with a large cast", and the word challenging in this case is not a lie. This is a fast paced, multi-cast changing script which leaves little room for error for its young cast in the performance. If the script isn't enough to handle for the young performers, director Christopher Elmer-Gorry and designer Carl Davies have made the situation even more complex for the actors with the set and stage work. Having to manhandle great panels on wheels and a huge cube, which also splits in two occasionally, during scene changes requires skill, coordination and cooperation of a high level. As if all this is not enough, the actual story is epic enough for the relatively small stage of the Royal. Attempting to form an apocalyptic world (albeit only happening in Plymouth) offers challenges in itself, but Agboluaje's script does that in a sort of apocalypse in the teac...

Review of The Killing Of Sister George at The Playhouse Theatre, Northampton

The Playhouse Theatre's The Killing Of Sister George offers to me the most unique review challenge yet as I have followed the creation process unlike any other, having had the privilege to watch a number of rehearsals. Seeing it from relatively early days of book in hand, to book down and to the penultimate dress rehearsal, I have seen it at at some very dramatic times. No one will disagree either that the final time I saw it, just one rehearsal away from going live in front of a paying audience, there was much still to refine. This review is of the fourth night and I will disregard as best as possible what I saw during rehearsals (with one very important exception). Written in 1964 by Frank Marcus, Sister George was an exceptionally controversial play at its time with its suggestions that its lead characters are in a lesbian relationship, still illegal at the time. The play itself is subtle in its telling, however the 1968 film is much more explicit, capitalising no doubt from t...